Making Soft Plastic Fishing Lures: 7 Best Kits and Plastisol Picks (2026)

Updated November 2026

If you want to start making soft plastic fishing lures at home, the first decision is which materials and tools to buy. Some kits focus on plastisol resin cubes, others on colorants, and others on injection molds that turn melted plastic into finished baits. This guide compares seven popular options for making soft plastic fishing lures, judged on resin formula, color range, mold and tool completeness, ease of use for beginners, and how well owners tend to describe the results. Each pick is matched to a specific type of angler.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product	Best for	Key feature
SPORTLIMIT Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 242 Medium Formula	Overall DIY bait making	Medium-firmness plastisol base
Eupheng PlastiCatch Series Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Rubber	Clear and realistic bodies	Crystal clear, low-odor, non-yellowing formula
Thenshop Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes, 12 Pack	First-time makers	12 cubes in natural colors
Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 112 Super Soft Formula	Very soft, action-heavy baits	Super soft formula
Eupheng 6 Color Plastisol Colorant Set	Custom color blends	Six colors, easy mixing, heat-resistant
PLASTISOL Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes – Starter KIT 6 Pack	Low-commitment starters	Over 16 oz total resin
INJEX Petite BASS Lure Making Kit	Molding and injection work	Injector, molds and six resin colors

SPORTLIMIT Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 242 Medium Formula

Best for: Overall DIY bait making with a balanced feel

This is a good fit for anglers who want one plastisol that works for worms, swimbaits and creature baits without tuning the recipe every time. Its medium formula sits between very soft and firm plastics, which suits most bass-style baits.

Key specs

• Plastisol base in the medium hardness range
• Sold as a fishing lure plastisol for melt-and-pour use
• Compatible with standard colorants and flavor additives

Pros

• Versatile hardness for many lure styles
• Melts evenly when heated to the manufacturer’s range
• Holds detail well in molds

Cons

• Not the softest option for finesse work
• Requires a separate mold and heat source

Bottom line: A strong default choice for makers who want one reliable resin for everyday baits.

View on Amazon

Eupheng PlastiCatch Series Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Rubber, Crystal Clear, Low Odor, Non Yellowing Soft Formula for DIY Fishing Lures

Best for: Clear and realistic bodies

Anglers who pour translucent baits, or who want colors to look true in the water, will value a crystal-clear, non-yellowing plastisol. The soft formula is aimed at lifelike action.

Key specs

• Crystal clear base for translucent colors
• Soft formula, labeled non-yellowing
• Low-odor plastisol for indoor pouring

Pros

• Clear base shows color additives accurately
• Low odor is more comfortable in home workspaces
• Non-yellowing helps stored baits keep their look

Cons

• Clear plastisol needs careful colorant dosing
• Soft formulas can tear more easily on fish-heavy days

Bottom line: Best for makers focused on realistic, see-through bait bodies.

View on Amazon

Thenshop Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes, 12 Pack, Natural Colors | 33.6 oz / 2 Pint

Best for: Starter bundles and first pours

New makers who do not want to buy resin, colorants and extras separately may find this multi-cube pack convenient. It covers a good amount of material for a first round of baits.

Key specs

• 12 plastic cubes, listed at 33.6 oz total (2 pints)
• Natural colors for basic bait tones
• Intended for bass, crappie and similar species

Pros

• Good quantity for the first several batches
• Natural colors suit many freshwater patterns
• Cubes are easy to portion and melt

Cons

• Limited color range without buying extra colorant
• Natural shades may not stand out in murky water

Bottom line: A practical choice for beginners who want to get pouring quickly.

View on Amazon

Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 112 Super Soft Formula

Best for: Very soft, action-heavy baits

Makers targeting finesse presentations, or baits meant to flutter and wobble with minimal rod input, tend to prefer a softer resin. This formula is built for that feel.

Key specs

• Super soft plastisol formula
• Designed for melt-and-pour lure making
• Compatible with common lure molds

Pros

• Soft feel for subtle action
• Pairs well with the brand’s medium resin for blending
• Easy to pour into thin mold sections

Cons

• Softer baits are more prone to tearing
• Can deform if stored in heat

Bottom line: The right pick for finesse-focused anglers who want a soft, lifelike feel.

View on Amazon

Eupheng 6 Color Plastisol Colorant Set for DIY Soft Fishing Lures

Best for: Custom color blends

If you already have a base resin and want to mix your own patterns, a colorant set is the piece you need. Six colors give a range of natural and high-visibility options.

Key specs

• Six colorants: six realistic natural and six high-visibility options as listed
• Designed for easy mixing into plastisol
• Labeled heat-resistant

Pros

• Lets you build custom shades
• Good balance of natural and bright colors
• Mixes into plastisol with simple stirring

Cons

• Does not include resin, so it is an add-on purchase
• Small color changes require careful measuring to repeat

Bottom line: Ideal for makers who already have resin and want more control over color.

View on Amazon

PLASTISOL Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes – Starter KIT 6 Pack, Over 16 oz Total Resin

Best for: Budget-minded starters

Anglers who want to try lure making without a large commitment can start with a smaller multi-pack. Sixteen ounces of resin is enough for a modest first session.

Key specs

• Six cubes, over 16 oz (1 pint) total resin
• Plastisol melt-and-pour format
• Suitable for basic bait molds

Pros

• Lower entry point for trial batches
• Simple cube format is easy to melt
• Good for testing colors before buying more

Cons

• Less material for frequent pouring
• Fewer color options than larger bundles

Bottom line: A sensible choice for a low-commitment first try.

View on Amazon

INJEX Petite BASS Lure Making Kit, 3 Soft Plastic Injection Fishing Lure Molds, Injector, 6 Resin Colors

Best for: Molding and injection work

Makers who want a complete system, with molds and an injector rather than only resin, may prefer a kit like this. It is aimed at producing consistent bass-sized baits with less guesswork.

Key specs

• Three soft plastic injection molds
• Injector included
• Six resin colors listed

Pros

• Complete starter system in one purchase
• Injector speeds up repeatable pours
• Good color variety for the included resin

Cons

• Fixed mold shapes limit custom designs
• Injection requires attention to temperature and air bubbles

Bottom line: Best for hobbyists who want molds, an injector and resin in a single kit.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Resin type and hardness

Plastisol is the most common material for making soft plastic fishing lures. Hardness is usually described as soft, medium or firm. Softer resins produce more action but tear more easily, while firmer resins hold up better on rocky bottoms and toothy fish. Choose a base that matches the baits you plan to pour most often.

Good picks for this: SPORTLIMIT Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 242 Medium Formula, Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 112 Super Soft Formula

Clarity and color

Clear plastisol lets colorants and glitter show true tones, while opaque bases hide mistakes but limit translucency. If you want a realistic shad or baitfish look, a clear base gives you more to work with. Natural color packs are easier for beginners, while colorant sets reward makers who like to experiment.

Good picks for this: Eupheng PlastiCatch Series Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Rubber, Eupheng 6 Color Plastisol Colorant Set for DIY Soft Fishing Lures

Kit completeness

Some products are only resin, while others include cubes, colorants or molds. Check whether you will also need a melting pot, a thermometer, molds, scent additives and a pouring tool. A complete kit saves time for beginners, but a resin-only purchase can be cheaper per pound if you already own the equipment.

Good picks for this: INJEX Petite BASS Lure Making Kit, Thenshop Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes, 12 Pack

Batch size and volume

Resin is sold by weight or volume, and the right amount depends on how often you pour. Six cubes and about 16 ounces may cover a handful of test batches, while larger packs suit regular makers. Estimate how many baits you plan to make per month before deciding.

Good picks for this: PLASTISOL Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes – Starter KIT 6 Pack, Thenshop Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Cubes, 12 Pack

Mold and injection compatibility

Check whether your resin is designed for open molds, injection molds or both. Injection systems usually require the resin to flow at a specific viscosity, and mismatched products can trap air or underfill cavities. Read the manufacturer’s temperature range before melting.

Good picks for this: INJEX Petite BASS Lure Making Kit, SPORTLIMIT Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 242 Medium Formula

Safety and workspace

Melting plastisol produces fumes and the material gets very hot. Work in a ventilated area, use heat-resistant gloves and never leave a melting pot unattended. Low-odor formulas make indoor pouring more pleasant, but ventilation is still important. If you have respiratory conditions, consult a medical professional before setting up a home pour station.

Good picks for this: Eupheng PlastiCatch Series Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Rubber, Eupheng 6 Color Plastisol Colorant Set for DIY Soft Fishing Lures

Storage and durability

Finished baits should be stored away from direct sunlight and heat, which can soften or deform them. Non-yellowing formulas help keep clear baits looking fresh over time. Keep resin cubes sealed and dry to prevent contamination.

Good picks for this: Eupheng PlastiCatch Series Plastisol Fishing Lure Making Plastic Rubber, Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 112 Super Soft Formula

FAQ

What do I need to start making soft plastic fishing lures?

At minimum you need plastisol resin, a heat-safe melting pot, a thermometer, a mold and a pouring vessel. Colorants and scent additives are optional but popular. Many beginners start with a kit that bundles resin and molds.

What temperature should plastisol be melted at?

Follow the manufacturer’s listed range for the specific product. Overheating can degrade the plastic and create fumes, so use a thermometer rather than guessing.

Is plastisol the same as silicone for lures?

No. Plastisol is a PVC-based melt-and-pour material, while silicone is a different polymer usually poured cold and cured. Each has different handling requirements and feel.

Can I use soft plastic lures I make for saltwater?

Many makers use plastisol baits in freshwater and inshore saltwater. Check that your resin and colorants suit your target species and local conditions, and rinse baits after use.

How do I make my baits softer or firmer?

Hardness is mainly set by the resin formula. Blending softer and firmer plastisols can give intermediate results, but follow the manufacturer’s mixing guidance to avoid inconsistent batches.

How long do homemade soft plastic baits last?

Durability depends on resin hardness, fish species and how the baits are stored. Store them cool, dry and out of direct sun, and inspect them for tears before each trip.

Is home lure making safe for children?

Melting plastic involves high heat and fumes. Children should never operate melting equipment, and adults should supervise any hobby pouring in the home. If you have health concerns, consult a qualified professional.

Conclusion

For most beginners, a medium plastisol like the SPORTLIMIT Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 242 Medium Formula is a versatile starting point. Anglers focused on clear, realistic bodies should look at the Eupheng PlastiCatch Series, while finesse-minded makers may prefer the Bait Plastics 112 Super Soft Formula. If you want to mix your own colors, the Eupheng colorant set is the logical add-on. Those who want a full system with molds and an injector will find the INJEX Petite BASS Lure Making Kit the most complete single purchase, and the Thenshop and budget starter cubes suit anyone testing the hobby first.

Sources

• Consumer product safety information on handling heated materials and home workshop hazards (cpsc.gov)
• Workplace guidance on fume exposure, ventilation and heat-related hazards (osha.gov)
• Fishing regulations and conservation information for anglers in U.S. waters (fws.gov)

Related reading

• Soft Plastic Fishing Lure Making Kit: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners
• 8 Best Soft Plastic Fishing Lure Kits for Bass and Freshwater Anglers (2026)
• 7 Best Fishing Lures Soft Plastic Kits for Bass and Freshwater (2026)
• 8 Best Soft Plastic Lures for Bass: Expert Picks for Every Need
• 6 Best Bass Soft Plastic Lures for Every Situation: Buyer's Guide

About the author